New vs. used bike

Shopping for a bike? We'll help you decide whether buying new or used offers better value.

Buying a bicycle isn't usually an everyday occurrence. Some buy a bike for half a year, some for a year, and some even for decades. What unites every bike buyer is one thing: they want the most quality for the least money.

Is it better to buy a new bike or a used one from a marketplace?

Why choose used?

In this article, I'll discuss the various pros and cons of buying a new or used bicycle. People buy used bikes almost exclusively for financial reasons. I don't see any other benefit. Price is the most crucial factor in their decision-making.

The decision-making process

A cyclist decides to buy a bicycle. They usually have a few models to choose from within their chosen budget, but used bikes can be acquired for a lower price. Whether that's a few percent or tens of percent depends on the current market situation. This, of course, changes according to demand.

For comparison – during the pandemic, you saw bikes on marketplaces for incredibly high prices. This was because there was a shortage… Conversely, after the pandemic, the situation reversed, and suddenly there was a large number of bikes on the market, which drove prices down.

Risks of buying a used bike

Let's look at an example. You want to buy a bike; a new one costs €3000, and a used one costs €2000.

1. Bike history

First, you need to check the bike's history. After all, it's an expensive item, and few people would fail to keep the warranty card, invoice, or proof of purchase for their bike. No one would knowingly want to buy a stolen bike.

2. Is it under warranty?

Bike warranties vary. Manufacturers of some premium bike brands offer a lifetime warranty on the frame, while others offer a 5- or 10-year warranty. Simply put, each brand handles it differently. However, the minimum warranty is legally mandated at 24 months for bikes purchased in Slovakia.

For frames where manufacturers offer a lifetime warranty, it's often tied only to the original owner, and as a “second owner,” you might encounter problems in the event of a potential warranty claim.

3. Problematic model

Bicycles have made significant progress recently, but you might still find a model where, for example, the rear triangle frequently and repeatedly cracked (or had another technical issue). This point essentially builds on the previous one, and if you plan to buy a potentially problematic bike model with a short or no warranty, you're taking a risk. With older models, there's often an issue with the availability of spare parts (e.g., derailleur hangers) or backward compatibility, as standards in the cycling world change quite rapidly.

4. (Ir)responsible owner

The cycling world is small. First, try to find out from friends if they know the seller and what their experience with them has been. Contact them, as a personal meeting (or at least a phone call) is crucial. Ask about the bike's service history, the intervals at which it was serviced, whether there were any problems with it, and so on.

Inspection and purchase

There are many bike scammers. A forgotten bike invoice? Condition not matching the description? My recommendation is to always buy a bike in person – unless you're 100% knowledgeable, this will help you avoid scams and buying a pig in a poke.

No matter how likable and trustworthy the seller seems, always check everything thoroughly. Be patient and meticulous so you don't regret a rushed pre-purchase inspection later. Various scams occur, such as a camouflaged frame crack and so on. Not often, but unfortunately, they do happen.

When buying a used bike, it usually ends there, and you're on your own. If the bike isn't under warranty, you can't claim it or get help in any other way. If you find any hidden defects or problems, the amount you saved can sometimes rapidly diminish.

In stock > 2 pcs

Sale -9% Marin Alpine Trail Carbon 1 29 bike, black/gray/blue

from 3,049 € -9% RRP 3,699 €

In stock > 2 pcs

Sale -9% Marin Bobcat Trail 3 29 bike, blue/yellow/purple

from 589 € -9% RRP 749 €

In stock > 2 pcs

-10% Marin Alpine Trail XR GX 29/27.5 bike, silver/black

4,049 € -10% RRP 4,499 €

In stock > 2 pcs

Clearance -13% Lapierre Edge 2.9 29 bike, blue

519 € -13% RRP 669 €

Why choose new

For a new bike at the aforementioned price of €3000, you'll go to a shop where expert staff will advise you. If you choose the online option, you probably already have a clear idea of the specific model.

A new bike is, of course, unused and comes with a full warranty. However, the price includes not just the bike, but also advice (if it's a quality shop), willingness to handle complaints and problems (here I would be cautious, as every seller likes to sell bikes, but few have good customer service), as well as guarantee/warranty/post-warranty service or service discounts.

It's your choice

This article is merely intended to highlight the issues surrounding bike purchases. I've primarily shared my experiences and knowledge in this article, as I've gone through this process at least ten times during my cycling career.

It's up to you to evaluate and consider whether you'll acquire a new bike with a full warranty or opt for a used bike with potential risks. Whether the money you save (in our example, €1000) is worth the potential risk is a decision I, unfortunately, cannot help you with.

Buying a used bike is usually more advantageous for entry-level models, where the owner is typically just trying out a new hobby, and it often happens that they don't get hooked, and the bike ends up on the marketplace after one season with minimal mileage.

For bikes with better equipment, the owner's intention is often to buy a new bike because the old one is already worn out and would require significant investment.

Other factors in bike selection

Whether to buy a used or new bike also depends on what stage of your cycling career you're in. If you just want to try cycling and plan to buy, say, your first test bike, then a used bike is also worth considering.

If you ride demanding gravity disciplines where bikes really take a beating, then you need to realise that every component on a bike has a lifespan. You never know what the previous owner did with the bike (if you're buying used), how and who rode it, or what crashes occurred.


Another factor is that if the components on the bike you're buying don't suit you, you'll probably want to replace them. With a used bike, you'd have to sell them off, but with a new one, the dealer can replace those components for you directly. This saves you time and possibly money.

Choose wisely

Make wise decisions and seek advice. Buying a bike is an important decision that isn't made lightly. On one hand, you might strike “the deal of the century”; on the other, you could be disappointed, and problems might just pile up. In any case, I wish you a successful purchase!